Uncyclopedia:VFH/Saint Durendrin

From Uncyclopedia, the content-free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search


Saint Durendrin (history, logs)

Article: Saint Durendrin

Score: -1 cat's eyes for bicycles

Nominated by: Spıke ¬ 13:45 16-Feb-13 13:45, February 16, 2013 (UTC)
For: 1
  1. Symbol for vote Nom & For. Who knew Uncyclopedia had no article on the Patron Saint of Discordianism? First go by new user Fango ahmet. Spıke ¬ 13:45 16-Feb-13

  • (changed to no vote) There are tens of thousands of patron Saints of Discordianism, they all play the drums. SPIKE is a Pope (and a patron saint of discordianism) All Hail Eris! 3:04 17-2-'13
Against: 2
  1. Against. seems too random. Mn-z 11:05, February 17, 2013 (UTC)
  2. Yeah, against too. EDIT: It was too random to begin with, I remembered it as being better. As it goes on it got randomly worse. So disregard everything after this line, except the link to my article. END OF EDIT --- That's what happens when an article is made to expand. The first section was originally the entire page, and it's brilliant (some of the original language is even better). But then it's way too random, and seems like filler. I voted for the first section. Many articles are fine with just that size, to expand a page means it has to be done with as much reading enjoyment as the start. One of my own favorites (to whore I guess, but as an example) is my Animals with feet war with animals with no feet. Short is okay if it works (most would say that page doesn't work, but to me it does). And you do realize that with our new user base of me, you, puppy, and a few admins, that any "no" vote kills a feature. So I'll give a go at this page later, and try to bring it somewhere up to VFD level, and then do a little more so it's at least not huffed by some future generation of VFD voters. Aleister 13:06 same day
Comments
  • I told the author that the first section was not a complete article and asked him to extend it. In its original state it was not featurable nor even keepable. Yes, Random is his humor style, or the only humor I understand, not knowing Slavic politics, but I enjoyed "cat's eyes for bicycles" (more than I enjoyed dick-slapping Alexander the Great). The resurrection stuff is serious froth. Aleister, whatever you do, involve Fango, as of course my set of nominations was not made to let you pad your notable FA count but to draw in the new users. Likewise the new Welsh one, except that he hasn't taken the bull by the horns yet but is mostly prettying up links. Spıke ¬ 13:19 17-Feb-13
    Like I mention above, ignore everything past the edit, including helping the article. You didn't ignore past the edit, thus finding fault in nothing of any solidness except letters with no meaning (the meaning was removed via the edit). I was going to help him out, then take credit for it to pad my FA count instead of letting a noob have a full feature and be happy as a hog in a pot. But my mind is now free to roam. Aleister 15:22 same day

VFH

← Back to summary VFH
← Back to full VFH

Personal tools
projects