This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Bar Mitzvah article.
|This article was nominated for deletion on 24 September 2005.
The result of the discussion was Keep.
This article seems to take anti-semitism beyond humour or irony towards racism. I'm not Jewish, but reading this article I don't think it belongs on Uncyclopedia
The problem is not that it's offensive, but that it's not funny enough to justify that offensiveness. Lame.
This belongs on the main page of uncyclopedia. That picture is off the charts hilarious on so many levels.
I am Jewish, and while I think some parts COULD be construed as anti-semetic, it was clearly written by a Jew (or at least mostly so) and is hardly offensive. And it's extremely hilarious. Then again, I'm pretty tolerant/can take a joke, so it might be offensive to others. --Drumstick
k i am a jew and i find it very offensive cuz i just had a bat mitzvah (same as bar mitzvah but for a girl) so ya !!
Hate to break to you Luther, but I'm jewish and I see nothing wrong with this. Sure yuo need a slightly twisted sense of humor to appreciate the hilarity of this article, but it's there. -Moshe ben Yitzchak
Um, it's high time we unprotected this page. I think it was featured in the past, but I think that was back in April. Come on. 184.108.40.206 17:37, 1 June 2006 (UTC)